Why Two Applicants with Same Land Get Different GTS Status?
One of the most confusing and frequently asked questions by farmers during Green Tractor Scheme (GTS) Phase 3 is: Why do two applicants using the same land record get different application statuses?
Across Punjab, many farmers—especially brothers, joint owners, or family members—applied separately for the Green Tractor Scheme using the same land. Surprisingly, one applicant may show “Under Verification” or “Shortlisted”, while the other shows “Rejected”, “No Record Found”, or “Pending”.
This situation has caused frustration, rumours, and doubts about fairness. However, the reality is more technical than most people think.
This detailed article explains all possible reasons, clears misconceptions, and tells farmers what to do next, based on how the GTS system actually works under the Government of Punjab.
Understanding How GTS Verification Works
Before blaming the system, it is important to understand that GTS verification is not based on land alone.
Each application is checked through multiple layers, including:
- CNIC verification
- Mobile number verification
- Land ownership linkage
- Application history
- System-level checks
Even if the land is the same, other factors can still differ.
Same Land Does NOT Mean Same Application Profile
This is the biggest misunderstanding among farmers.
Two applicants may share:
- Same land
- Same Fard
- Same Khasra numbers
But still differ in:
- CNIC status
- Mobile number linkage
- Ownership percentage
- Application accuracy
That is why GTS statuses can be different.
Main Reasons Why Same Land Gets Different GTS Status
Below are the most common and genuine reasons behind this issue:
1. CNIC-Based Individual Verification
GTS treats every applicant as a separate individual, even if land is shared.
If one CNIC:
- Matches NADRA records perfectly
- Has updated details
And the other CNIC:
- Has outdated info
- Has name spelling mismatch
Their application status will differ.
👉 Land is secondary; CNIC is primary.
2. Mobile Number Registered on CNIC
OTP verification is critical.
If:
- Applicant A uses a mobile number registered on their CNIC
- Applicant B uses a SIM registered on someone else’s CNIC
Then Applicant B’s application may:
- Remain pending
- Face verification delay
- Get rejected
This happens even if land is 100% the same.
3. Joint Ownership Percentage Difference
In many families:
- Land is jointly owned
- Ownership shares are unequal
Example:
- Brother A owns 60%
- Brother B owns 40%
If scheme rules require minimum land share, one may qualify while the other does not.
4. One Applicant Already Benefited Earlier
GTS system checks previous subsidy history.
If:
- One applicant received tractor subsidy in earlier phase
- Other applicant did not
Then:
- One may be marked ineligible
- Other may move forward
Even with same land, past benefits matter.
5. Data Entry Mistakes in One Application
Small mistakes cause big problems.
Common errors include:
- Wrong CNIC digit
- Incorrect tehsil or district
- Misspelled name
- Wrong land area entered
If one applicant filled the form correctly and the other made errors, their statuses will differ.
6. System Sync Delay (Very Common)
Sometimes:
- One application is verified earlier
- Other is still syncing with land records
This results in:
- One status showing “Verified”
- Other showing “Pending”
This difference is temporary and often resolves later.
7. Duplicate or Suspicious Applications
If two applications from same land:
- Are submitted repeatedly
- Look similar in data
- Are flagged as duplicates
The system may:
- Process one
- Hold or reject the other for review
This is an anti-fraud measure, not discrimination.
8. Different Application Submission Time
Verification does not happen simultaneously.
One applicant may:
- Get verified earlier
- Move to next stage
While the other:
- Is still in queue
This timing difference creates temporary status mismatch.
9. Land Record Update Issues
If land:
- Was recently transferred
- Is inherited
- Has mutation pending
One applicant’s data may sync properly, while the other does not.
This causes status difference even on same land.
Myths About Same Land, Different Status (FALSE)
❌ “System is biased”
❌ “Someone paid an agent”
❌ “Officials manually changed result”
✅ Truth:
GTS Phase 3 is automated and digital. No manual interference is involved.
What To Do If Your Status Is Different from Co-Owner?
Step 1: Stay Calm
Status differences are common and often temporary.
Step 2: Check Your Own Details
Verify:
- CNIC accuracy
- Mobile number registration
- Land details
Step 3: Avoid Reapplying
Multiple applications can make things worse.
Step 4: Wait for Verification Completion
Final decisions come after full scrutiny, not during early stages.
Should You File a Complaint?
At early stages:
- ❌ No need
Only file a complaint if:
- Official appeal window opens
- Government announces grievance process
Until then, patience is advised.
Will Final Selection Still Be Fair?
Yes. According to officials:
- Final selection considers complete verification
- Temporary status differences do not decide final result
- Equal opportunity is ensured
Why GTS Uses CNIC Over Land
Because:
- Land can be shared
- CNIC identifies individual eligibility
- Prevents misuse of subsidies
This ensures fair distribution.
Lessons for Future Applicants
Farmers should:
- Use own CNIC-linked SIM
- Enter data carefully
- Avoid agents
- Apply once only
Correct application = smooth verification.
Importance of Transparency in GTS Phase 3
Despite technical issues, GTS Phase 3 is:
- More transparent than previous schemes
- Fully digital
- Free from manual favouritism
Status confusion does not mean unfairness.
Final Words
The issue of two applicants with the same land getting different GTS status is mainly due to CNIC-based verification, data accuracy, ownership share, and system processing stages—not discrimination or corruption.
Farmers are strongly advised to:
- Focus on their own application accuracy
- Ignore rumours
- Avoid agents
- Wait for official updates
With patience and correct information, deserving farmers will be treated fairly under the Green Tractor Scheme.
Many Punjab farmers are confused after seeing different GTS statuses for applications submitted on the same land. Officials say verification is CNIC-based and differences occur due to data accuracy, ownership share, and system processing delays.
